What the Latest Consumer Reports Survey Means in California
The latest Consumer Reports auto survey was released December 4, 2025. It is a national owner survey, not a ruling on any California warranty claim.
Consumer Reports released its 2026 Automotive Brand Report Card on December 4, 2025. That's the latest annual reliability package we could verify. In the sources we checked, it has not published a newer annual survey that replaces it. The results are national. They matter here because the same models are sold and serviced in California, and because a warranty repair in this state is judged under the Song-Beverly Act, not under a magazine score.
The press release says hybrids that don't plug in have, on average, about 15 percent fewer problems than gas cars. It says electric vehicles and plug-in hybrids have, on average, about 80 percent more problems than gas cars. For half the brands in that year's rankings, the least reliable car is a plug-in hybrid or a fully electric vehicle. Seven of the ten least reliable cars are plug-in hybrids or electric vehicles. Battery, charging, and drive-system problems are among the ones commonly reported. The survey is Consumer Reports' ranking of cars, not a reason to buy or skip a particular one without looking at the repair file.
What Consumer Reports measured
The December 4, 2025 release describes the report card as a brand-level look at vehicle quality. Consumer Reports said it used road-test scores of more than 200 new vehicles, safety results, and reliability and satisfaction data from member surveys. Those surveys covered about 380,000 vehicles, which it described as a 27 percent increase over the year before. The surveys cover model years 2000 through 2025, plus a few early 2026 models. Members were asked about problems in the previous 12 months, in up to 20 areas, including the engine, electric motors, the transmission, and in-car electronics.
The Car Reliability FAQ, updated December 9, 2025, adds the method. The data were collected during the 2025 calendar year. Members marked problems they considered serious because of cost, failure, safety, or downtime. Warranty problems count. Problems caused only by a crash, or due only to a recall, don't. Predicted reliability for a new model uses the past three model years if the vehicle wasn't redesigned, and one or two years if it was redesigned in 2025 or 2024.
The FAQ says not every trouble spot is weighted the same. Engine, major engine cooling, transmission, drive system, electric motor, and electric-vehicle battery problems are weighted more heavily because they're more likely to take the car out of service. In-car electronics and broken trim are weighted less. They're still counted. The electronics list includes a display that freezes or goes blank, phone pairing, backup and other cameras, Android Auto and Apple CarPlay, replacement of infotainment hardware, and software updates sent over the air.
What the same-day article added
An article updated the same day, "Who Makes the Most Reliable New Cars?," lines up with the press release and adds detail. It says Lexus, Subaru, and Toyota lead the brand reliability ratings, with Honda and BMW next. It says a majority of hybrid cars, minivans, SUVs, and trucks have average or better reliability. Of 26 brands, 13 of the least reliable models are an electric vehicle or a plug-in hybrid, and no hybrid is on that list. Within Kia, Consumer Reports places the Carnival Hybrid at the top of that brand's models in the survey and the EV9 at the bottom.
The same article says the plug-in version of several models tends to have worse reliability than the gas or conventional-hybrid version. It names the BMW X5, Ford Escape, Kia Sportage, Lexus NX, Lincoln Corsair, Mitsubishi Outlander, Toyota Prius, and Volvo XC60 plug-in hybrids as examples with average reliability that still rank worse than their gas or hybrid counterparts. Those are Consumer Reports' comparisons. We didn't repeat the measurements.
The trouble-spot lists differ by powertrain. Gas vehicles are scored on 17 areas. Electric vehicles are scored on up to 12, with the electric motor, the battery, and charging in place of the engine and transmission. Hybrids are scored on 19. Plug-in hybrids are scored on 20, because they carry the gas-vehicle list plus the electric motor, battery, and charging. A plug-in can be marked down for problems a gas car can't have, and for problems an electric car can't have. That's one reason the scores aren't a single identical test.
How to use this if you live in California
The survey is a reasonable place to start if you're comparing a hybrid, a plug-in, and a gas version of a model before you buy. Consumer Reports says predicted reliability is a statistical judgment from owner reports, not an inspection of the car on the lot. A redesign year may rest on less history. A score doesn't tell you whether the VIN in front of you has an open recall. That question belongs on NHTSA's VIN lookup.
If you already own the car, the useful local fact is the repair history at the dealer, not the brand's place on a national list. A California warranty claim turns on whether a nonconformity substantially impairs use, value, or safety, and on whether the manufacturer had a reasonable chance to fix it. When it applies, the presumption in Civil Code section 1793.22 looks at repair attempts and days out of service within 18 months or 18,000 miles. It doesn't look at a Consumer Reports score. A model the survey praises can still have one car with a substantial defect. A model it criticizes can still conform to its warranty.
Electronics complaints are in the survey and are weighted more lightly than a failed engine or battery. They still matter under California law when they substantially impair use or safety. A backup camera that doesn't work, a screen that blanks out the speedometer, or a driver-aid fault that returns after updates is a repair-file question. The note on software updates explains how those visits can be counted. The qualification guide explains the presumption without using survey rankings as a shortcut.
Figures left out on purpose
The press release mentions an average new-car price and a hybrid-sales figure attributed to the Department of Energy. Both are left out. The price isn't needed to understand the reliability findings, and we didn't separately check the sales figure against a Department of Energy table. Predicted scores for every model sit behind Consumer Reports' membership pages. The figures above are what the press release and the two public articles say in plain text.
We also didn't find a California-only cut of the survey. Nothing in the December 2025 release says the 15 percent or 80 percent figures were computed from California members alone. Treat them as national averages. Your dealer, your mileage, and your repair orders are the California file. If those orders already show the same complaint coming back, the pages we keep updated are the qualification guide and the lemon-law overview. The December 2025 figures will go out of date when Consumer Reports publishes the next annual package.
Sources
Disclaimer: The information is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice, nor does it constitute a guarantee, warranty, or prediction regarding the outcome of any legal matter. Reading it or contacting Kalantaryan Law Group does not create an attorney-client relationship. Kalantaryan Law Group, PC is responsible for the content.
Questions About a Warranty Repair?
Speak directly with an attorney about the vehicle. The consultation is free. Contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Call (818) 945-0900 Request a Consultation