Serving the Entire State of California Injured? No Fee Unless We Win. No fees and no costs if there's no recovery. (818) 945-0900 ENES
Your Rights

When Software Updates Become Repeat Repair Visits

Infotainment is the most-reported problem area in the latest dependability study. A dealer visit that updates software to fix a reported defect can be a repair attempt under California law.

A lot of dealer visits are now a software update. J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Vehicle Dependability Study, released February 12, 2026, says infotainment is still the biggest category of long-term problems, and that over-the-air updates often don't leave the owner feeling the car got better. Consumer Reports' reliability FAQ, updated December 9, 2025, lists those updates and infotainment faults among the trouble spots it asks about. Neither study is a lemon-law ruling.

The Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act doesn't have a chapter titled "software." It counts attempts to repair a nonconformity. A dealer visit that updates or reflashes software to address a problem you reported can be one of those attempts. An update that was never tied to a complaint is harder to count.

What J.D. Power said about updates

The press release says owner views of dependability have moved toward technology and software glitches. After three years, problems rose by 2 per 100 vehicles from the prior study, to an industry average of 204. Infotainment was 56.7 problems per 100 vehicles, the highest of the nine categories. Exterior was next, at 27.5.

On updates, 40 percent of owners said they got a software update in the past 12 months. Of those owners, 27 percent said the update improved the vehicle, and 58 percent said they noticed no difference. More than half of the updates, 63 percent, were done over the air. In the press release's words, those over-the-air updates resulted in a nearly 14 percent increase in problems this year, which it states as 2.5 problems per 100 vehicles. The study used 33,268 original owners of 2023 model-year vehicles. It's a national survey of 2023 vehicles after three years, not a count of California warranty visits in 2026.

Four of the top five industry problems were tied to phone connections. Android Auto and Apple CarPlay connectivity was the single most common problem for a third straight year, at 8.9 problems per 100 vehicles. Built-in Bluetooth was 5.5. Wireless charging pads were 5.1. The manufacturer's own app was 4.7. J.D. Power said those four account for 24.2 problems per 100 vehicles, close to half of the infotainment category. A connection complaint isn't automatically a warranty defect. It's the kind of complaint that now produces repair visits, including visits where the only "part" is new software.

What Consumer Reports asks about

The FAQ, from surveys collected in 2025 and published with the December 4, 2025 auto report, asks about displays that freeze, phone pairing, cameras, Android Auto and Apple CarPlay, infotainment hardware replacement, and software updates sent over the air. Electronics are weighted less than an engine, transmission, electric motor, or battery, because those are more likely to leave the car unusable. That weighting isn't the legal test. A camera or a safety alert that doesn't work can still matter under a warranty.

The statute counts repair attempts

Civil Code section 1793.2(d) says that if the manufacturer can't conform a new motor vehicle to the express warranty after a reasonable number of attempts, it must promptly replace the vehicle or make restitution, and you may choose restitution. Section 1793.2(b) says the repair should start within a reasonable time and, unless you agree in writing, the car should conform to the warranty within 30 days. Delay the manufacturer can't control extends that period.

Section 1793.22, the Tanner Consumer Protection Act, is the presumption. Inside 18 months from delivery or 18,000 miles, whichever comes first, a reasonable number of attempts is presumed if the same nonconformity has been repaired four or more times, or two or more times when it's likely to cause death or serious bodily injury if the car is driven, or the car has been out of service for repairs more than 30 calendar days. You have to notify the manufacturer directly only if the warranty or owner's manual clearly says so, including the address. The 30 days extend only for delay the manufacturer can't control. The presumption can be rebutted.

The word in the presumption is "repair." The statute doesn't say the manufacturer has to replace a hardware part for the visit to count. When an authorized dealer, acting for the manufacturer, applies a software update to a problem you brought the car in for, that visit is an attempt to repair it. The repair order should say what you complained about and what software work was done. "Performed update, no problem found" on a visit where you reported a blank backup camera is a different record from a visit with no complaint at all.

Four software visits for a screen that goes blank can be four attempts at the same nonconformity. Two visits for a defect likely to cause death or serious bodily injury if the car is driven can meet the safety track. A backup camera or a driver-assistance fault may or may not meet that description. The statute states the standard and doesn't list software symptoms that automatically qualify. Days the car sat waiting on a software release count toward the 30 days when it was out of service for repair.

What isn't settled

We didn't find a published California appellate opinion that says every over-the-air update counts as a repair attempt, whether or not you reported a problem. An update that arrives overnight, that you didn't ask for, and that isn't documented as the repair of a specific complaint, isn't the same record as a dealer visit for a stated problem. A manufacturer may argue the update was maintenance, that several symptoms were separate problems, or that the car wasn't out of service because you could still drive. Those arguments are why the repair orders, the dates, and any message about the update matter. The statute doesn't settle them in the abstract.

The presumption also has limits that a software update doesn't remove. It's aimed at new motor vehicles and the express warranty, inside the mileage and time window. Outside that window, section 1793.2 can still apply, without the presumption, if the number of attempts was reasonable on the facts. A qualified third-party dispute process, if you were notified of it the way section 1793.22 describes, can affect when the presumption may be used. The time-limits guide plus the qualification guide cover those conditions on the pages we keep updated. A software version number isn't enough to score a claim.

Keep every repair order, even when the "repair" is a software number on the last line. Keep the date the problem returned, a photo of the warning, and any over-the-air notice that names the module and the date. If the warranty told you to notify the manufacturer in writing, keep that letter and the address you used. If the car waited at the dealer for a calibration or a part, the out-of-service dates belong in the same file.

You can ask the dealer for a software update without a lawyer. Song-Beverly comes up when the same substantial problem has already had repeated repair attempts, or the car has been out a long time, and it still doesn't conform. Kalantaryan Law Group reviews those files for owners throughout California. The Glendale office is at (818) 945-0900. Bring the repair orders.

Disclaimer: The information is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice, nor does it constitute a guarantee, warranty, or prediction regarding the outcome of any legal matter. Reading it or contacting Kalantaryan Law Group does not create an attorney-client relationship. Kalantaryan Law Group, PC is responsible for the content.

Questions About a Warranty Repair?

Speak directly with an attorney about the vehicle. The consultation is free. Contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Call (818) 945-0900 Request a Consultation