Serving the Entire State of California Injured? No Fee Unless We Win. No fees and no costs if there's no recovery. (818) 945-0900 ENES
Truck Accidents

Why Truck Accident Claims in California Are Different

A collision with a commercial truck can involve federal driving-time limits, a California intrastate exception, and records the carrier is required to keep for six months.

A crash with a commercial truck in California is still a negligence case. It differs from a crash between two private cars in ways that show up in the first weeks. The driver was under hours-of-service rules. More than one company may share responsibility. Some of the useful records are electronic, and they are not all kept for the same length of time. The hours, the records, and the deadlines come from the federal and California sources that set them.

They apply on highways across the state, not only near the firm's Glendale office. A trip that crosses a state line and a trip that stays in California can sit under different driving-time limits. You need to know which trip it was before the log means much.

Federal hours for property-carrying trucks

For property-carrying trucks in interstate commerce, 49 CFR section 395.3 is the federal limit. A driver needs 10 consecutive hours off before driving, then may not drive after 14 consecutive hours on duty, and may drive only 11 of those hours. Except for the short-haul exceptions in section 395.1(e), driving stops if more than 8 hours of driving pass without a consecutive 30-minute break. That break can be off duty, in the sleeper, on duty but not driving, or a mix. Weekly, a driver may not drive after 60 hours on duty in 7 days if the carrier doesn't run every day, or after 70 hours in 8 days if it does. Either stretch can reset with 34 or more hours off. The carrier may not require a driver to go past those limits.

Passenger-carrying vehicles use different limits, in a different section. A bus crash doesn't use the 11-hour rule for property-carrying trucks.

The California intrastate exception

Vehicle Code section 34501.2(a) says hours-of-service rules for interstate or intrastate commerce shall be consistent with the U.S. Department of Transportation rules in Title 49, as those rules exist now or are later amended. Interstate driving follows the federal rule.

Subdivision (b) makes exceptions for intrastate hauls that aren't carrying hazardous substances or hazardous waste. On those trips, maximum driving time in a work period is 12 hours for a truck or truck tractor. A driver of a tank vehicle over 500 gallons hauling flammable liquid is limited to 10 hours. Except for a narrow emergency provision, nobody may drive after 80 hours on duty in any 8 consecutive days. A California-only nonhazardous haul isn't judged by the federal 11-hour and 70-hour limits, and an interstate haul isn't judged by the 12-hour figure. The bill of lading and the log show which trip it was. CHP form 800D, the Terminal Manager's Compliance Checklist, says terminals are inspected under Vehicle Code sections 34501 or 34501.12, and it asks whether drivers stay inside sections 34501.2, 34501.3, and 34501.4 and Title 13.

How long the logs have to be kept

Most interstate drivers record duty status on an electronic logging device. Section 395.8(k) says the carrier keeps those records and supporting documents for at least 6 months from receipt. The driver keeps the prior 7 days on board while on duty. Section 395.22(i) requires a 6-month backup on a separate device. FMCSA's published answer cites both. CHP 800D asks the same question under Title 13, sections 1213 and 1234: keep the original log and the supporting documents at least six months. Six months is a minimum, not a promise the carrier still has the file when you ask.

Supporting documents are how someone checks the log against the trip. If the log says the driver was off duty and a fuel receipt or a dispatch message says otherwise, that conflict is why the papers matter. Asking only for "the ELD printout" can miss them.

The engine data is a different problem

People call the engine-control module a black box. The hours rules cited above don't set a retention period for engine data, cameras, or telematics. There isn't one federal period that covers all of those systems. Carriers and their vendors set overwrite schedules, and some of that data can be gone long before the six-month log period ends. A written request to preserve logs, the ELD backup, maintenance files, the bill of lading, and any engine or camera data has to go out early. The letter doesn't create data the carrier never recorded. It tells them not to delete what they have.

More than one company may be responsible

The driver was behind the wheel. The motor carrier is the company the hours rules address when they say the carrier shall not permit or require the driver to go over the limits. The company that owns the tractor, the company that owns the trailer, a maintenance contractor, and the company that loaded the cargo are not always the name on the door. A broker or a shipper that arranged the load is another possible party, and whether that company shares responsibility depends on what it actually did. Brokers are not generally liable just because they arranged the load. The name on the door isn't the whole list. The log, the lease if the truck was leased on, the bill of lading, and the carrier's file are what sort it out. The police report usually isn't enough.

The injury deadlines still apply

Section 335.1 still gives two years for an action for injury or death caused by the wrongful act or neglect of another. If a public entity is part of the claim, a Caltrans road, a city truck, or a county vehicle, section 911.2 still requires a claim for death or injury within six months. The federal log-retention period doesn't extend those deadlines, and those deadlines don't require the carrier to keep camera footage for six months. The guides on filing deadlines and government claims cover presentment. The truck-accident page describes the firm's work on these cases.

These are the general deadlines, and they can differ. Section 352 can pause the lawsuit period while an injured person is under 18 or lacks the legal capacity to make decisions, but that pause doesn't apply to a public-entity claim. If the six-month presentment period has passed, section 911.4 allows a written application for leave to present a late claim, made within a reasonable time and not later than one year after the claim accrued. A discovery rule can also move the start of the period to when the person knew, or reasonably should have known, of the injury and its cause. Ask a lawyer before you treat any of these dates as your last day.

If you were hurt, get care, get a report number, and get the other driver's information, including the carrier name, the USDOT number if it's posted, and the trailer number. Bring those to a consultation instead of trying to decide on your own whether the driver was over hours. The office number is (818) 945-0900. A consultation doesn't create an attorney-client relationship until there is a written agreement.

Disclaimer: The information is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice, nor does it constitute a guarantee, warranty, or prediction regarding the outcome of any legal matter. Reading it or contacting Kalantaryan Law Group does not create an attorney-client relationship. Kalantaryan Law Group, PC is responsible for the content.

Hurt in a Truck Crash? Ask for a Free Case Review.

Speak with an attorney about what happened. There is no cost for the consultation, and no fee unless we win.

Call (818) 945-0900 Request a Consultation